It was during one replay that I realized Peyton Manning is not the cold-blooded quarterback he is perceived to be. Don’t get me wrong; Manning is a clutch quarterback, having orchestrated 45 career game-winning drives, but most of those game-winners have been during regular season.  Manning is an exceptional performer during the regular season but fails to translate it into the postseason.
 
Out of the 17 games Manning has played in the playoffs, he has only won nine times.  Not exactly the stats of a great playoff performer and it doesn’t warrant all-time great status.  For comparison, New England quarterback Tom Brady is 14-4 in the playoffs with three Super Bowl rings.  I’m just sayin’.
 
We’ll leave the statistics and Manning vs. Brady debate aside to guys like Bill Simmons and other pretentious football experts.  For now, let’s focus on Peyton Manning and what he is capable of doing next season.  During the replay of Manning’s incomplete pass to Reggie Wayne on a fourth down late in the fourth quarter, there were several things not seen before on Manning’s face.  As the Saints’ defense formed a circle and were on the brink of collapsing on Manning, the four-time MVP’s face told it all: desperation and fear laced his entire expression as he released a tight spiral that Wayne would fail to catch.
 
Check the replay again of the Colts’ final play and you’ll see not a confident all-time great but a scared expression that would rival a rookie quarterback’s face during a potential game-winning drive.  It was the first time Manning failed to show confidence and composure despite being within striking distance of the end zone on a fourth-down.  It was a sad sight to see; possibly the greatest quarterback of all-time reduced to a mere mortal not sure of the outcome.
 
From that moment on Manning knew he would take most, if not all, of the blame, which is unfair to him considering the Colts’ secondary couldn’t stop Drew Brees from getting into a rhythm in the second half and special teams couldn’t contribute anything positive to Indianapolis’ Super Bowl cause.  Manning’s situation is eerily similar to the Los Angeles Lakers’ Kobe Bryant.  Bryant was the best player in the NBA during the 2007-2008 season and led the Lakers to the Finals.  The Lakers were heavily favored against the Celtics, just like the Colts were against the Saints.
 
Many analysts chose the Lakers to beat the Celtics mainly because of one reason: Kobe Bryant.  Again, similar to why analysts chose the Colts to prevail in Super Bowl XLIV: Peyton Manning.  The Lakers proceeded to get whooped by the Boston Celtics in six games.  The same fear and desperation enveloped Bryant’s face during the final seconds of the already decided game.  It is the same fear and desperation that wrapped Manning’s face in the waning seconds in Super Bowl XLIV.
 
The loss left a nasty taste in Bryant’s mouth, the same taste Manning has right now.  Next season, Bryant could not be denied and won his fourth NBA championship.  I expect Manning to do the same.  That’s what the great ones do: come back from a disappointing loss, re-define their legacy and come back with a vengeance.
 
Manning played great until Tracy Porter recognized the route and stepped-in to deliver the deciding blow to the Colts.  Considering the time that Manning puts in the film room, he will not make the same mistake
again. Just wait until next season: Manning will raise his play to an even higher level and will lead the Colts to a Super Bowl win because that’s the only way to spit the nastiness out.  Just ask Kobe.

Related posts:

1. Peyton Manning and Drew Brees are on Pace for Some Big Raises in the Offseason Unlike the NBA or the MLB, the NFL tends to have quite a few players that stay loyal to the franchise that drafted them or took a chance on them when no one else would.  Usually...
2. Who Will Win the QB Battle Between Peyton Manning and Tom Brady? The one matchup in the NFL every single season that every football fan looks forward to is the head to head AFC battle between Tom Brady’s New England Patriots and Peyton Manning’s Indianapolis Colts.  Manning and...
3. Can New Orleans Saints’ Safety Darren Sharper Stop Peyton Manning? It is very seldom in the NFL that we see two great offenses in the Super Bowl instead of a great offense going up against a great defense.  Last season we saw Kurt Warner and the...
4. Peyton’s Place Peyton Manning is already considered one of the top quarterbacks ever to play the game, despite only having won one Super Bowl.  His one ring prevents him from being THE best the game has ever...
5. The Kick that Changed It All It is funny that the kick that changed it all was not a field goal or a deep punt that prevented the Colts' great field position.  It was a gutsy onside kick, which changed the momentum...
6. Can the Lions Overcome Last Year’s Failure? The Detroit Lions were the punch lines of poorly thought-out jokes last year and rightfully so.   As everybody in the universe knows (football fan or not) the Lions were the only team in league history...